Food & Wine

Restaurants in Edinburgh: five places for whisky, steak and a long dinner


Whisky in an old pump house, steak in a former bank and candlelit dinner by the castle: five Edinburgh restaurants, and the hotels closest to each.

image

Adrian Møller Haugan

Colourful shopfronts on Victoria Street in EdinburghJim Divine / Unsplash

You walk down the Royal Mile on a dark December afternoon, and the lights are on in the closes. Edinburgh has grown into a food city, and the centre is small enough to walk to most of its restaurants.

In short: restaurants in Edinburgh

We recommend five restaurants in Edinburgh. They are The Devil’s Advocate and The Witchery in the Old Town, Hawksmoor in the New Town, Number One at The Balmoral and Scran & Scallie in Stockbridge. All were open. Last checked: October 2026. Stay in the Old Town or New Town and you can walk to four of them.

Our first choice for a stay: The Balmoral by Waverley station, with Number One downstairs. Check availability and prices at The Balmoral

The Devil’s Advocate

The whisky bar and restaurant sits in an old Victorian pump house in a close in the Old Town. The shelves behind the bar hold more than 300 whiskies, and the cocktail list is long.

Guests in the dark bar at The Devil’s Advocate in EdinburghCourtesy / Devil´s Advocate
Good food and whisky in EdinburghThe Devil´s Advocate has over 300 different types of whisky available for those who want to test some of the best that Scotland has to offer.

Portions are generous, and lunch works well after a visit to Edinburgh Castle.

Stay nearby: The Caledonian, with views of the castle. Check availability and prices at The Caledonian

Hawksmoor

Hawksmoor occupies the former premises of the National Bank of Scotland. The group was founded by childhood friends Will Beckett and Huw Gott, and is known for high-quality steak.

Dining room with leather banquettes at Hawksmoor in EdinburghCourtesy / The Hawksmoor
Hawksmoor EdinburghHawksmoor is located in the former premises of the National Bank of Scotland.

The menu also has Scottish seafood. After dinner, head down to the bar in the basement.

Stay nearby: Kimpton Charlotte Square in the New Town. Check availability and prices at Kimpton Charlotte Square

Scran & Scallie

The gastropub in Stockbridge was founded by chefs Tom Kitchin and Dominic Jack. The name means roughly ‘food and scallywag’ in Scots.

Bright dining room with brick wall at The Scran & ScallieCourtesy / Scran and Scallie / Marc Miller Photography
Gastropub The Scran and ScallieThe Scran and Scallie is run by Scottish celebrity chef Tom Kitchin and his Swedish wife Michaela.

The menu is Scottish pub food made with local produce, from oysters to sausage and mash. The pub has held a Bib Gourmand in the Michelin Guide. Stockbridge is a little way from the centre, so leave time for a walk along the Water of Leith.

The Witchery

The Witchery sits just below Edinburgh Castle, with oak panelling, leather chairs and candlelight. The room is made for a long dinner for two.

Laid tables with white cloths at The Witchery in EdinburghCourtesy / The Witchery
Warm and cozy restaurant in EdinburghThe interior at The Witchery is the perfect setting for a romantic dinner in distinctly Scottish surroundings.

If you want to stay over, The Witchery has its own suites in the same style. Prestonfield House, run by the same owner, is an alternative a little outside the centre.

Number One

Number One sits downstairs at The Balmoral, the hotel with the clock tower by Waverley station. The restaurant holds four AA Rosettes and is recommended in the Michelin Guide, according to Rocco Forte Hotels.

The main menu is a seven-course tasting menu. The restaurant usually closes for a few weeks in January, so check the dates before you book.

Which restaurant suits you?

For whisky and a relaxed evening, choose The Devil’s Advocate, and for a good steak, go to Hawksmoor. Scran & Scallie suits Sunday pub food.

The Witchery is the place for a romantic dinner, while Number One suits a celebration.

The dining room at Number One at The Balmoral in EdinburghCourtesy / The Balmore Hotel
Michelin star restaurant at The Balmore HotelNumber One is the name of the award winning restaurant at The Balmore Hotel in Edinburgh.

Stay right between the restaurants

The Balmoral: Number One downstairs


The Balmoral stands where Princes Street meets North Bridge, by Waverley station. The Old Town and the restaurants around the Royal Mile are on one side, the New Town on the other. The hotel has three restaurants, among them Number One, and the Scotch whisky bar. After dinner in town you are back in minutes, and the train from London stops just below.

Check availability and prices

Where to stay in Edinburgh: four hotels close to the restaurants

Edinburgh is a city for walking, and the Old Town and New Town are close together. Choose your hotel well and you can have dinner at The Witchery and be back in your room five minutes later.

The whisky bar at The Balmoral with bottles from floor to ceilingHotels.com (Expedia Group)
The BalmoralThe whisky bar at The Balmoral holds hundreds of bottles from across Scotland.

The Balmoral: Number One downstairs

The hotel with the great clock tower by Waverley station is also home to Number One, one of the best known restaurants in the city. Dinner is just a lift ride away. Princes Street and the Old Town are right outside the door.

Book your stayThe Balmoral
See dates and prices
Restaurant in a bright glasshouse with plants at Kimpton Charlotte SquareHotels.com (Expedia Group)
Kimpton Charlotte SquareKimpton Charlotte Square sits in a row of Georgian houses in the New Town.

Kimpton Charlotte Square: the Georgian New Town

An elegant hotel in a row of Georgian townhouses on Charlotte Square, with a courtyard, a bar and a spa. From here you can walk to Hawksmoor on St Andrew Square and to the restaurants of Stockbridge, home of The Scran and Scallie.

Book your stayKimpton Charlotte Square
See dates and prices
Dark, elegant bar at The Caledonian in EdinburghHotels.com (Expedia Group)
The CaledonianThe Caledonian’s bar is a dark, elegant spot for a drink with castle views nearby.

The Caledonian: castle views

The old railway hotel in the West End has rooms looking straight at Edinburgh Castle. The Witchery, at the top of the Royal Mile, is a short walk away, and the hotel bars are perfect for a drink before dinner.

Book your stayThe Caledonian
See dates and prices
Lounge with dark colours, fabrics and candlelight at Prestonfield HouseHotels.com (Expedia Group)
Prestonfield HousePrestonfield House feels like a country house, with candlelit lounges and rich colours.

Prestonfield House: a country house in the city

If you love The Witchery, you will love Prestonfield. The manor house has the same owner, the same theatrical interiors and peacocks in the grounds, and is only a short taxi ride from the centre.

Book your stayPrestonfield House
See dates and prices

Frequently asked questions about restaurants in Edinburgh

Is Edinburgh a good food city?

Yes. Edinburgh has restaurants at every price point, from gastropubs with a Bib Gourmand to tasting menus in the grand hotels. The centre is small, so you can walk between the Old Town and the New Town in about a quarter of an hour. Many of the best places cook with Scottish produce, such as seafood, game and whisky.

What is The Devil's Advocate?

The Devil's Advocate is a whisky bar and restaurant in an old Victorian pump house in the Old Town. It offers generous portions, high-quality ingredients, excellent service and more than 300 whiskies, plus a wide cocktail list. Book ahead at weekends.

Are the restaurants in Edinburgh far apart?

No. One of the advantages of Edinburgh is its small, compact centre, so the different food experiences are close together. That makes it easy to combine several restaurants and bars in one evening. Book ahead in August, when the festivals fill the city.

Where should I stay in Edinburgh to be close to the restaurants?

Stay around Princes Street or in the New Town and you can walk to all five restaurants. The Balmoral has Number One in the same building, and Kimpton Charlotte Square is close to Hawksmoor and the walk to Stockbridge. The Caledonian is a short walk from The Witchery below the castle.

Sources

The restaurant reviews are based on Adrian Møller Haugan's visits for Picolo. The facts have been checked against the restaurants' own sites, among them The Devil's Advocate and Hawksmoor Edinburgh, and against the Michelin Guide, where Scran & Scallie holds a Bib Gourmand. Hotel details come from the hotels and Hotels.com. All five restaurants were open when we checked. Last checked 2 November 2026.

Keep reading